Stanford Laws College – Robert Crown Rules Library

Finest Legal off California

• Opinion
• Docket

Anybody v. Figueroa (1986) 41 Cal.3d 714 , 224 Cal.Rptr. 719; 715 P.2d 680 [Crim. Zero. 24252. Best Legal regarding California. April eight, 1986.]

(Advice by Bird, C. J., with Mosk, Broussard, Grodin, JJ., and you will Takei (Taketsugu), J., concurring. Independent concurring viewpoint because of the Reynoso, J., having Lucas, J., concurring.)

John K. Van de- Kamp, Attorneys Standard, Edward P. O’Brien, Assistant Attorney General, Derald Age. Granberg and you may Robert R. Granucci, Deputy Lawyer Standard, having Plaintiff and you will Respondent.

The principal matter displayed through this desire is if the fresh demonstration legal, into the a good prosecution into marketing from unqualified bonds, erred [41 Cal.three dimensional 718] for the teaching this new jury that certain “Corporation Promissory Notes” was indeed “securities” in online payday GA the meaning of the organization Ties Laws. (Corp. Password, § 25000 et seq. fn. 1)

Stanford Legislation College – Robert Crown Rules Collection

Joseph and Dennis Figueroa appeal of a wisdom off belief for you to definitely number of selling unqualified ties. (§§ 25110, 25540.) New jury deadlocked into thirteen most counts, seven so-called up against Joseph and you will four up against Dennis. After that, an excellent mistrial is actually stated towards men and women counts, and they were ignored with the knowing that they could be experienced from the legal to possess restitution purposes. One another appellants got regards to probation which have requirements and additionally restitution, a suspended condition jail name, and society services.

During the middle-February out of 1979, Arlo Kurrle responded to a publicity which in fact had starred in the fresh San Jose Mercury Development. The fresh offer stated “Solar & Energy Company. Mate need that have $eight,100 or higher. Active otherwise nonactive.” Kurrle titled one of the a few phone numbers placed in new ad and you can spoke so you’re able to Joseph Figueroa, who explained an existing insulation company and his desire to build to the solar power.

Kurrle came across Joseph and his son, Dennis, a day later. This new Figueroas advised Kurrle regarding the Figueroa Insulation & Opportunity Co., Inc. (Insulation) where Dennis are president. The solar energy team would feel a business. Kurrle found out about a few other businesses, Figueroa Economic Insurance policies Features, Inc. (Insurance) and you may Figueroa Organization & Financial Experts (Financial).

Joseph and you can Dennis advised one Kurrle dedicate $ten,100 within organization. The money would be to be taken on purchase of insulation gizmos plus the having phones accustomed solicit mortgage consumers.

In the first fulfilling, Kurrle and Joseph discussed whether Kurrle were to be active into the the organization. Kurrle conveyed interest in which have a primary character, maybe on the conversion process otherwise administration section.

A short time later, Kurrle titled Joseph and agreed to give the firm $10,100. You will find no talk about what setting Kurrle’s resource [41 Cal.three-dimensional 719] create take, however, Kurrle “is actually thought with respect to financing . that would be noted.” In the dialogue, Joseph told Kurrle he might possibly be an officer in one single of your Figueroa agencies.

Along side next 30 days, Kurrle paid the cash to the Figueroas within the four independent installment payments evidenced from the four dos-seasons cards. fn. 2 The latest cards would be to earn ten percent appeal a-year. Kurrle met with the choice to just take percentage in the bucks otherwise offers of your own company. This new fourth loan repayment, getting $dos,five hundred, constituted the cornerstone with the charges on what the fresh new Figueroas have been ultimately convicted. fn. step 3 Kurrle generated that loan giving the newest Figueroas a payable to help you Dennis. The loan was observed by a great “Firm Promissory Notice” from Insulation which was closed of the Dennis. During the associated area it mentioned:

With the Worth Acquired, on the otherwise Prior to 24 months once big date, in place of elegance The Figueroa Insulation & Opportunity Providers, Inc., intends to spend into the purchase out-of Mr. Arlo Kurrle, from San Jose, California or at the their office or home. [¶] The sum of $dos,500 a couple of thousand cash & 500 during the speed out-of ten% % annum up to paid back. . [¶] . The [sic] assented and you can knew, this particular organization note is due a keen [sic] payable inside the a couple of years out of go out on the note and its [sic] subsequent assented and know, one to appeal is to be paid down yearly [sic] every year, but every due and you may payable April 27th, 1981. . “